What is more important on defense?

You can't really justify which is more important because they are all important ets that a successful team has at their disposal. I suppose I should say Defensive-D-man though, it seems to be the most natural or basic form of defense. And to answer your second question I would have to say all defensive, though it is insanely ludicrous to even consider. I would choose that based off of my previous opinion. For the third question I would take Mike Komisarek and Anton Volchenkov based off the fact that they are steady players that show reasonable consistency as well they are very physical and defensive. I would prefer a Big Goal over a Big Hit any day, you win games with goals. "you play to win the game"- Herman Edwards.